BenefitsUSA
Back to Blog
GuideNovember 19, 2026·14 min read·By Jacob Posner

Medigap Birthday Rule 2027: States That Let You Switch Plans

Which states have a Medigap birthday rule in 2027, how long each window lasts, and which plans you can switch to without health questions.

The Medigap birthday rule is a state law that gives people who already have a Medicare Supplement (Medigap) policy a short window each year, tied to their birthday, to switch policies without answering health questions. There is no federal birthday rule. As of November 2026, we verified birthday-type rules on state insurance department pages or in state law for 15 states: California, Delaware, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maryland, Nevada, Oklahoma, Oregon, Utah, Virginia and West Virginia, with New Mexico's rule starting January 1, 2027. New York goes further and lets you apply in any month. The rules differ a lot: some let you change companies, some keep you with your current company, and almost all limit you to the same or lesser benefits.

This guide covers each verified state's window, what you can switch to, and how to use the window without leaving a gap in coverage. For Medigap basics, see Medicare Supplement (Medigap) Explained 2026. To compare what each plan letter covers, see the Medicare Supplement Plans 2027 Comparison Chart.

Why the Birthday Rule Matters

Under federal law, your strongest right to buy Medigap is your 6-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period. It starts the month you are 65 or older and enrolled in Part B. During those 6 months, an insurer cannot turn you down or charge you more because of your health.

After that window closes, most states let insurers ask health questions (called medical underwriting) when you apply for a new Medigap policy. If you have had a heart attack, cancer treatment, or a new diagnosis, an insurer can say no or charge more. That leaves many people stuck in a policy whose premium keeps rising, even when a different company sells the exact same plan letter for less.

Because Medigap plans are standardized, a Plan G pays the same benefits no matter which company sells it. A birthday rule lets you use that fact. In states where you can change companies, you can move from one company's Plan G to another company's Plan G once a year, and the new company cannot reject you for health reasons.

Medicare costs more when you set it up wrong.

A late signup adds a penalty that lasts for life, and most people never claim the programs that pay part of their costs back. See what applies to you in about 3 minutes. Free.

Free · 3 minutes · No SSN to start

See what I can get

Medigap Birthday Rule States: Verified 2026 to 2027 Rules

This table lists only states whose rule we confirmed on the state insurance department's website or in the state statute or regulation. Other states have proposed or adopted similar rules; if your state is not listed, check with your state insurance department or your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) before assuming you have no rights.

StateWindowWhat you can switch toCan you change companies?
California60 days starting on your birthdaySame or lesser benefitsYes
DelawareStarts 30 days before your birthday, stays open at least 30 days afterSame or lesser benefitsYes, existing or new carrier
Idaho63 days starting on your birthdaySimilar or lesser coverageYes, any company selling in Idaho
Illinois45 days starting on your birthday (ages 65 to 75)Equal or lesser benefitsNo, same insurer or its affiliate
Indiana1 month before to 1 month after your birthday (age 65+)Same plan letter onlyYes, that is the purpose
KentuckyWithin 60 days of your birthdaySame plan onlyYes, must be a different insurer
Louisiana63 days starting on your birthdayEqual or lesser plan letterNo, same insurer or its affiliate
MarylandYour birthday plus the 30 days afterEqual or lesser benefitsYes
NevadaAt least 60 days starting the first day of your birth monthSame or lesser benefitsYes
Oklahoma60 days starting on your birthdayEqual or lesser benefitsYes, same or different carrier
OregonYour birthday plus the 30 days afterSame or lesser benefitsYes
Utah60 days starting on your birthdayComparable or lower tier planNo, same issuer only
VirginiaAt least 60 days starting on your birthdaySame benefits as your current planYes, any insurer in Virginia
West VirginiaStarts the first day of your birth month, ends 60 days laterSame or lesser benefitsUsually no, same insurer or affiliate
New Mexico (from Jan. 1, 2027)60 days starting in your birthday month (age 65+)Equal or lesser valueNot yet detailed by the state

Sources: California Department of Insurance senior advisory; Delaware Department of Insurance SB 71 consumer alert; Idaho Department of Insurance (SHIBA); 215 ILCS 5/363; Indiana Department of Insurance HEA 1260 fact sheet; KRS 304.14 (2023 Ky. Acts ch. 182, HB 345); La. R.S. 22:1112; Maryland Insurance Administration; NRS 687B.352; Oklahoma Insurance Department FAQ; OAR 836-052-0143; Utah H.B. 258 (2025); Va. Code § 38.2-3611; West Virginia Enrolled H.B. 4869 (2026); New Mexico Aging and Long-Term Services Department.

Year-round states

New York does not need a birthday rule. The New York Department of Financial Services says insurers must accept a Medigap application from a Medicare enrollee at any time of year, and prices are community rated, so they do not climb with age. Details are in our New York Medigap 2027 guide.

State-by-State Details

California

The California Department of Insurance says Medigap policyholders get 60 days of open enrollment following their birthday each year, and the new policy must have the same or lesser benefits. You can buy from a different company. California's window used to be 30 days, so older articles may still say 30.

Delaware

Delaware's rule took effect January 1, 2026 under Senate Bill 71. The window opens 30 days before your birthday and stays open at least 30 days after. You can buy a policy with the same or lesser benefits from your current carrier or a new one, and the carrier cannot rate you up. It applies to people who bought a policy in Delaware and still live there, and to people who moved to Delaware with an out-of-state policy. The department warns that switching high-deductible policies mid-year restarts the deductible.

Idaho

Since March 1, 2022, Idaho policyholders get a 63-day guaranteed issue period starting on their birthday. The Idaho Department of Insurance says you can buy the new plan from any company offering policies in Idaho, but you cannot upgrade benefits.

Illinois

Illinois law gives people ages 65 to 75 who have a Medigap policy a 45-day window starting on their birthday. The catch: you can only buy from the same insurer or an affiliate licensed in Illinois, and the new policy must have equal or lesser benefits. That makes the Illinois rule most useful for moving to a lower-cost plan letter within your company's family, not for shopping other companies.

Indiana

Indiana's rule started January 1, 2026 and was amended by HEA 1260 for policies issued or renewed on or after March 15, 2026. If you are 65 or older and have a Medigap policy, you can move to the same lettered plan at a different company, from one month before your birthday to one month after. The Indiana Department of Insurance gives the example of Plan G at Company 1 to Plan G at Company 2. You cannot switch letters, such as F to G. The new plan starts the first day of the month after you sign the application.

Kentucky

Kentucky's rule took effect January 1, 2024. You must already have a Medigap policy, apply within 60 days of your birthday, apply to a different insurer, and keep the same plan. The new policy cannot have a waiting period or pre-existing condition exclusion, and state law caps what the insurer can charge you.

Louisiana

Louisiana gives a 63-day window starting on your birthday. You can buy any Medigap policy from the same issuer or an affiliate licensed in Louisiana. The no-health-questions protection applies when the new plan letter has benefits equal to or less than your old one.

Maryland

Since July 1, 2023, Maryland policyholders with a policy issued in Maryland get a window covering their birthday and the 30 days after. The Maryland Insurance Administration says you do not have to stay with your current carrier, and the switch must be to equal or lesser benefits. Carriers may make the window longer but not shorter. You must submit the application inside the window; the state says it does not have to be fully processed by then.

Nevada

Nevada's window opens on the first day of your birth month and stays open at least 60 days. Any insurer selling Medigap in Nevada must accept you for a policy with the same or lesser benefits without health questions, a price surcharge, or a pre-existing condition exclusion. Insurers must notify you 30 to 60 days before the window opens.

Oklahoma

The Oklahoma Insurance Department says the 60-day window starts on your birthday, which counts as day one. You can switch to equal or lesser benefits with the same or a different carrier. You qualify only if you have not gone more than 90 days without Medigap coverage, and employer group Medigap plans are not included.

Oregon

Oregon's rule lets you cancel your Medigap policy and buy one with the same or lesser benefits from your birthday through the 30 days after. The insurer cannot deny or price the new policy based on your health. Oregon's Division of Financial Regulation publishes the chart it uses to decide which plans count as "same or lesser."

Utah

Utah's rule started May 7, 2025. For 60 days starting on your birthday, your current issuer must let you move to a comparable or lower-tier plan it offers, without medical underwriting. It does not give you a right to switch companies.

Virginia

Virginia's rule (2025 Acts, chapters 530 and 540) opens a window on your birthday that lasts at least 60 days. You can buy a policy with the same benefits as your current coverage from any insurer selling in Virginia. Insurers must send notice 15 to 30 days before the window opens.

West Virginia

West Virginia's law took effect June 11, 2026, and it is narrower than most. Your current policy must have been in force for at least 24 months, and each replacement policy then needs another 24 months before you can use the rule again. The window starts the first day of your birth month and ends 60 days later. You must stay with the same insurer or an affiliate, unless neither has accepted applications for a same-or-lesser plan for at least 12 months.

New Mexico (starts 2027)

New Mexico's Senate Bill 21 was signed in March 2026 and takes effect January 1, 2027. The state's aging department says Medigap enrollees 65 and older will get a 60-day window starting in their birthday month to switch to plans of equal or lesser value without being denied or charged more. Ask the Office of Superintendent of Insurance how it applies before your 2027 birthday.

What "Same or Lesser Benefits" Means

Most birthday rules let you move down or across, not up. Moving to the same letter at a different company is the clearest case and works in every state above that allows a company change. Moving to a plan with fewer benefits, such as a plan with copays you do not have now, is allowed in most of these states. Moving to a richer plan is not protected; that application can go through medical underwriting.

States define the ladder differently, and some publish a chart (Oregon) or a list of allowed moves (Maryland). Before you apply, ask the insurer in writing whether your move counts as equal or lesser under your state's rule.

How to Use the Birthday Rule: Step by Step

  1. Find your window. Check your state's start day (birthday, birth month, or a month before) and length in the table above. Some states require insurers to mail you a notice ahead of time.
  2. Check eligibility conditions. Illinois covers ages 65 to 75. Indiana and New Mexico cover 65 and older. West Virginia needs 24 months of coverage. Oklahoma needs no gap over 90 days.
  3. Compare prices for the same letter. Your SHIP or state insurance department can explain how to compare premiums. Many state departments publish rate guides.
  4. Apply inside the window. Submit the application before the window closes. Keep a copy with the date.
  5. Do not cancel your old policy yet. Wait until the new policy is issued and you know its start date. Delaware's department notes you may pay two premiums for one month to avoid a gap.
  6. Cancel the old policy in writing so it ends the day the new one starts.

Federal rules also give you 30 days after a new Medigap policy starts to decide whether to keep it, as long as you pay the premiums for both during that month.

Birthday Rule vs Other Ways to Switch

SituationHealth questions allowed?Where it applies
6-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period at 65 or older with Part BNoAll states
Federal guaranteed issue rights (for example, your Medicare Advantage plan leaves your area)No, for the plans the law listsAll states
State birthday ruleNo, within that state's limitsStates listed above
Year-round applicationNoNew York
Any other timeUsually yesMost states

For the federal situations, see CoveredUSA's guide to Medigap guaranteed issue rights.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the Medigap birthday rule a federal law?

No. It is created by each state, and each state sets its own window, age limits and plan limits. Federal law only guarantees the 6-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period and specific guaranteed issue situations.

Can I use the birthday rule to leave Medicare Advantage and get Medigap?

Generally no. The rules above apply to people who already have a Medigap policy. Delaware separately lets people leaving Medicare Advantage during the fall or January to March enrollment periods buy a Medigap policy without being denied, though insurers may rate them individually.

Can I upgrade from Plan N to Plan G on my birthday?

Not under most birthday rules, because Plan G has more benefits. You can still apply, but the insurer may ask health questions and can say no.

Does my age at the time of switching change my premium?

It can. In states where insurers price by attained age, a new policy is priced at your current age. Some states, such as Kentucky and Delaware, limit how insurers can rate people who switch. See Medigap Plan G Cost by Age 2026-2027.

What is the Medigap anniversary rule?

Some states tie a similar window to your policy's anniversary date instead of your birthday. We have not listed any anniversary-rule state here because we have not yet verified one on a state source for this guide. Ask your state insurance department whether one applies to you.

Does the birthday rule apply if I moved to a new state?

It depends on the state. Delaware applies it to people who moved in with an out-of-state policy, but not to people who bought in Delaware and moved away. Maryland's rule covers policies issued in Maryland. Ask the insurance department in the state where you live now.

Who can help me for no charge?

Your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) offers free, unbiased Medicare counseling. Your state insurance department can answer questions about your state's rule and handle complaints if an insurer refuses a valid application.

The average person finds $16,900 a year in benefits they qualify for.

See your real number, and how to claim each one. Some you apply for yourself, and we tell you exactly where.

Free · 3 minutes · No SSN to start

See what I can get