Medigap Plan F and Plan G cover the same costs except one: Plan F pays the Medicare Part B deductible and Plan G does not. CMS set that deductible at $292 for 2027 (up from $283 in 2026). So switching from F to G saves money whenever your Plan F premium is more than about $24.33 a month ($292 a year) above the Plan G premium you can get. In Iowa's official rate guide, most companies charged more than that gap. The catch is health questions: outside a protected window, a new insurer can usually turn you down, so never cancel Plan F until Plan G is approved in writing.
This page is the head-to-head decision for people who already have Plan F. If you want the background on Plan F itself, who can still buy it, and why its premium rises, read our Medicare Supplement Plan F 2027 guide. For Plan G prices at each age, see our Plan G cost guide.
Plan F vs Plan G: The One Coverage Difference
Medigap plans are standardized by letter in every state except Massachusetts, Minnesota and Wisconsin. A Plan G from any company has the same benefits as a Plan G from any other company. The same is true for Plan F.
| Cost Original Medicare leaves you | Plan F | Plan G | 2027 amount (CMS) |
|---|
| Part A hospital deductible | Pays | Pays | $1,776 per benefit period |
| Hospital coinsurance, days 61 to 90 | Pays | Pays | $444 a day |
| Lifetime reserve days | Pays | Pays | $888 a day |
| Skilled nursing coinsurance, days 21 to 100 | Pays | Pays | $222 a day |
| Part B coinsurance (usually 20%) | Pays | Pays | Varies |
| Part B excess charges | Pays | Pays | Up to 15% above Medicare's rate |
| Blood, hospice coinsurance | Pays | Pays | Varies |
| Foreign travel emergency | 80% | 80% | Up to plan limits |
| Part B deductible | Pays | Does not pay | $292 a year |
Source: CMS fact sheet "2027 Medicare Parts A & B Premiums and Deductibles," released November 17, 2026.
That is the whole difference. On Plan G, you pay the first $292 of Medicare-approved Part B costs in 2027, then Plan G pays your share of everything else Medicare covers. Neither plan covers prescription drugs, dental, vision or hearing aids.
For a side-by-side of the two most common plans for people new to Medicare, see CoveredUSA's Plan G vs Plan N comparison.
The Break-Even Math
Use your own numbers. The formula is short:
- Take your current monthly Plan F premium.
- Subtract the monthly Plan G premium you have been quoted.
- Multiply by 12.
- Subtract $292 (the 2027 Part B deductible you would now pay yourself).
If the result is above zero, Plan G costs less for the year, even if you meet the full deductible. Most people who see a doctor a few times a year do meet it, so this is a fair worst case.
| Plan F costs this much more than Plan G | Extra you pay per year for F | After the $292 deductible | Which costs less in 2027 |
|---|
| $15 a month | $180 | F saves you $112 | Plan F |
| $24.33 a month | $292 | $0 | Break-even |
| $40 a month | $480 | G saves you $188 | Plan G |
| $50 a month | $600 | G saves you $308 | Plan G |
| $100 a month | $1,200 | G saves you $908 | Plan G |
If you rarely use Part B services and never meet the deductible, Plan G saves you even more than this table shows.
What real prices look like
We checked every Plan F and Plan G price in the Iowa Medicare Supplement & Premium Comparison Guide from the Iowa Insurance Division's SHIIP program, premiums effective October 1, 2026. Twenty-nine companies listed both plans.
| Age | Median Plan F | Median Plan G | Median gap at the same company | Companies where F costs more than $292/year extra |
|---|
| 65 | $241/mo | $201/mo | about $40/mo ($478/yr) | 22 of 29 |
| 70 | $265/mo | $219/mo | about $44/mo ($527/yr) | 22 of 29 |
| 75 | $313/mo | $258/mo | about $50/mo ($597/yr) | 23 of 29 |
| 80 | $374/mo | $311/mo | about $53/mo ($641/yr) | 25 of 29 |
Monthly figures are the guide's annual premiums divided by 12 and rounded. The gap column is the median of each company's own Plan F price minus its own Plan G price.
Most people who bought Plan F based on age turned 65 before 2020, so in 2027 they are at least 72. The 75 and 80 rows are the ones to look at. At the median company, moving from F to that same company's G saves about $305 a year at 75 and about $349 a year at 80, after paying the full deductible.
Shopping other companies can change the picture more. At 75, the median Plan F was $3,758 a year and the lowest Plan G was $2,234 a year. If you qualified for that lower price, the difference is $1,524, or about $1,232 a year after the deductible. That is an example from one state, not a quote, and the lowest price today can rise faster later (see "Rate history" below).
The other side matters too. In two or three of the 29 companies, Plan F actually cost the same or less than that company's Plan G at some ages. Your own company's prices, not a national average, decide the math.
The Real Risk: Health Questions
The math is the easy part. The hard part is getting approved.
Medicare.gov says that in most cases you "won't have a right under federal law to switch Medigap policies" unless you are in your 6-month Medigap open enrollment period or have a guaranteed issue right. Most Plan F holders are years past that window. So in most states, the company selling you Plan G can:
- Ask health questions on the application
- Turn you down
- Charge you more than its standard rate, depending on your state's rules
Applications commonly ask about recent hospital stays, planned surgery, cancer treatment, heart and lung conditions, kidney dialysis, and some medications. If you have a serious condition, you may not pass.
This is why the order of steps matters. Your Plan F is guaranteed renewable. Your company cannot cancel it for health reasons as long as you pay the premium. If you cancel F first and then get denied for G, you could end up with no Medigap at all.
A few more rules from Medicare.gov:
- When you get the new policy, you have 30 days to decide whether to keep it (the "free look" period). You pay both premiums for the month you have both.
- If you have had your current policy for less than 6 months, the new one may make you wait before it covers a pre-existing condition.
- Some companies let their own Plan F customers move to their Plan G with fewer or no health questions. That is a company practice, not a federal right, so ask your current company before you shop elsewhere.
States That Make Switching Easier
Some states give people who already have Medigap a yearly window to change plans without health questions. What matters for an F-to-G move is whether the rule lets you change to a plan with fewer benefits, or only to the same letter. Plan G has fewer benefits than Plan F, so "equal or lesser benefits" rules usually allow it.
| Type of state rule | Example states | Does it allow F to G? |
|---|
| Year-round, no health questions | New York, Connecticut | Yes |
| Birthday window, equal or lesser benefits, any company | California (at least 60 days starting on your birthday), Idaho, Nevada, Oregon, Oklahoma, Wyoming, Maryland, Delaware | Generally yes |
| Birthday window, equal or lesser benefits, same company or affiliate | Illinois (ages 65 to 75, 45 days from your birthday), Louisiana, Utah | Yes, with your current company |
| Birthday or anniversary window, same plan letter only | Missouri, Kentucky, Virginia, Indiana | No. You could move to Plan F at another company |
| New for 2027 | New Mexico (birthday window starting January 1, 2027) | Generally yes |
Window length, start date and which companies you can move to differ by state, and states change these laws often. Confirm the current rule with your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) or state insurance department before you apply.
If you live in a "same letter only" state, you can still use your window to compare Plan F prices across companies. A cheaper Plan F with no health questions can sometimes beat a Plan G you would have to pass underwriting to get.
Federal guaranteed issue rights also reopen the door in specific situations, such as your Medigap company going bankrupt or misleading you. These have deadlines, usually 63 days. For people first eligible before 2020, the federal rights generally guarantee Plans A, B, C, F, K or L. That protects your ability to buy Plan F from another company, but not necessarily Plan G, so ask your SHIP what your state adds.
When Staying on Plan F Makes Sense
Switching is not always the right move. Plan F is often still the better choice if:
- You would not pass health questions and you do not live in a state with a window that covers F to G. Keeping coverage you cannot replace matters more than saving a few hundred dollars.
- Your company prices F close to G. If the gap is under about $24 a month, F costs the same or less once you count the $292 deductible.
- You are in a closed window and near a big change. If you are about to have surgery or start treatment, wait. Do not risk a gap.
- You value no Part B deductible bills and can afford the higher premium now and as it rises.
Does Plan F's premium rise faster?
Not reliably, and do not switch on that assumption alone. Plan F has been closed to people new to Medicare since 2020, so its group of policyholders only gets older, and many people expect that to push rates up. But CSG Actuarial's review of 2026 rate filings found that plans still open to new buyers averaged increases of about 14%, compared with about 11% for closed plans like F. The Iowa Insurance Division has also said it does not expect Plan F rates "to dramatically increase" because of the 2020 change. What matters is your own company's history. Look at your last three rate letters.
Rate history and pricing method
Before you switch, ask any company two questions:
- How is Plan G priced? Attained-age (rises with your age), issue-age (based on your age when you buy), or community-rated (same for everyone). A low attained-age price at 75 can climb quickly.
- How much has its Plan G premium gone up in each of the last three years?
Moving to a cheaper G that rises much faster can wipe out your savings in a few years. No company can promise your premium will stay the same.
How to Switch From Plan F to Plan G, Step by Step
- Find your current Plan F premium and your company's Plan G price. Call your company and ask whether you can move to its Plan G, and whether that requires health questions.
- Get other Plan G prices. Use the Medicare.gov Medigap plan finder or your state insurance department's rate guide. Many states publish every company's prices.
- Run the break-even math. Monthly difference times 12, minus $292.
- Check your state's switching rule with your SHIP. Find yours at shiphelp.org or call 1-877-839-2675. SHIP counselors offer free, unbiased help and do not sell insurance.
- Apply for Plan G while you keep Plan F. Answer every health question truthfully. A false answer can let the company cancel the new policy later.
- Wait for written approval and the start date. Then use your 30-day free look period to confirm everything is in place.
- Cancel Plan F in writing, with a clear end date that lines up with Plan G's start date. Expect to pay both premiums for one month.
Your Part B premium does not change either way. It is $209.40 a month in 2027 for most people, up from $202.90 in 2026, and you pay it on top of any Medigap premium.
High-Deductible Plan G as a Third Option
Some companies sell high-deductible Plan G. You pay the first $3,050 in 2027 of covered costs before it pays, in exchange for a much lower premium. It is a bigger change than F to G and usually also requires health questions. Our Medigap comparison chart shows how it fits with the other plans.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between Plan F and Plan G?
Plan F pays the Medicare Part B deductible and Plan G does not. Every other benefit is the same. The Part B deductible is $292 in 2027, up from $283 in 2026.
Should I switch from Plan F to Plan G?
Switch if Plan G costs you more than about $24.33 a month less than Plan F (that is, more than $292 a year less) and you can get approved. Do not switch if you would fail health questions and have no state window or guaranteed issue right, or if your company prices F and G within about $24 a month of each other.
Is Plan F better than Plan G?
Plan F covers slightly more, the $292 Part B deductible. Whether it is the better buy depends on price. In Iowa's official guide, most companies charged Plan F holders more than $292 a year extra for that coverage.
Can I switch from Plan F to Plan G without health questions?
Sometimes. You can in New York and Connecticut year-round, in states with a birthday rule that allows "equal or lesser benefits," and at some companies that allow their own customers to move to a lower plan. Otherwise, most states let the new insurer ask health questions.
If I drop Plan F, can I get it back later?
You stay eligible to buy Plan F because you became eligible for Medicare before 2020. But outside a protected window, the company can ask health questions and turn you down. Treat dropping Plan F as permanent unless you are sure you could pass underwriting.
What is the Part B deductible in 2027?
CMS set it at $292 for 2027, an increase of $9 from $283 in 2026. Plan F pays it. On Plan G, you pay it yourself.
When is the best time to switch from Plan F to Plan G?
There is no national switching season for Medigap. The October to December Medicare open enrollment period is for Medicare Advantage and Part D, not Medigap. If your state has a birthday rule, your window is the best time. Otherwise, you can apply any month, as long as you keep Plan F until Plan G is approved.
Benefits USA is not a government agency and does not sell insurance. This page is general information, not a recommendation of any plan or company. Premiums shown are examples from one state's official guide and are not quotes. Sources: CMS fact sheet "2027 Medicare Parts A & B Premiums and Deductibles" (November 17, 2026); CMS CY 2027 Medigap notices (high-deductible amount); Medicare.gov, "Change Medigap policies"; Iowa Insurance Division SHIIP, Iowa Medicare Supplement & Premium Comparison Guide (premiums effective October 1, 2026); CSG Actuarial, "Open Block vs. Closed Block: Med Supp Rate Changes in 2025 and 2026"; California Insurance Code section 10192.11; state insurance department birthday-rule laws.