BenefitsUSA
Back to Blog
GuideNovember 18, 2026·12 min read·By Jacob Posner

New York Medigap 2027: Year-Round Enrollment, Community Rates

New York Medicare supplement plans: apply any month, same price at 65 or 85, no health questions. 2026 premium ranges by plan and 2027 rules.

New York Medicare supplement (Medigap) plans work differently from most of the country. State law requires every insurer that sells Medigap in New York to accept your application in any month of the year, and it cannot turn you down or charge you more because of your health. Prices are community rated, so a 66-year-old and an 86-year-old in the same region pay the same premium for the same plan. The trade-off is price: as of November 1, 2026, a Plan G in New York costs between about $265 and $840 a month depending on the insurer and region, according to the New York State Department of Financial Services (DFS).

That combination changes the Medigap versus Medicare Advantage decision. In most states, picking Medicare Advantage at 65 can lock you out of Medigap later. In New York, the door back to Medigap stays open. This guide covers how the rules work, what plans cost, the 2027 federal figures, and how to apply.

For the national basics, see Medicare Supplement (Medigap) Explained 2026. For New York's other programs, see our New York benefits page.

New York Medigap Rules vs Most States

RuleNew YorkMost other states
When you can applyAny month of the yearMainly your 6-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period, plus limited guaranteed issue situations
Health questionsInsurer cannot deny you or charge more because of your healthAfter your open enrollment, insurers can ask health questions and deny you
How age affects priceCommunity rated: same price at any ageMany plans raise prices as you age (attained-age rating)
Under 65 on Medicare due to disabilityInsurers must sell to you on the same termsNo federal right to buy Medigap under 65; depends on the state
Pre-existing condition waitUp to 6 months, shortened or removed by prior coverageUp to 6 months during open enrollment

Sources: NY DFS, Information for Medicare Beneficiaries; NY DFS premium comparison tables.

Year-round enrollment

DFS states that New York law and regulation require any insurer writing Medigap to "accept a Medicare enrollee's application for coverage at any time throughout the year." Insurers also cannot make premium distinctions because of health status, claims experience, or medical condition.

This applies whether you got Medicare by turning 65 or through disability or end-stage renal disease. A 50-year-old on Medicare after two years of SSDI can buy a Medigap policy in New York on the same terms as a 65-year-old.

The pre-existing condition waiting period

Year-round enrollment does not always mean coverage of every condition on day one. DFS says a New York Medigap policy may include up to a 6-month waiting period before pre-existing conditions are covered. That wait is reduced by prior creditable coverage, as long as you did not have a gap in coverage longer than 63 days.

In practice, someone switching from a Medicare Advantage plan or job-based coverage straight into Medigap usually has creditable coverage to count. Someone who has had no coverage at all for months is the person most likely to face the full wait. Ask the insurer, in writing, whether a waiting period applies to you before you cancel anything.

Community rating: why prices look high at 65

Community rating means the insurer charges everyone in a region the same premium for a given plan, regardless of age. You do not get a low "age 65" price that climbs every birthday. You pay a pooled price from the start.

That makes New York premiums look high next to quotes for a 65-year-old in an age-rated state. Over 15 or 20 years, the picture changes, because your New York premium only moves when the insurer gets a rate change approved by DFS, not because you got older. For how age-rated pricing works elsewhere, see Medigap Plan G Cost by Age 2026-2027.

Medicare costs more when you set it up wrong.

A late signup adds a penalty that lasts for life, and most people never claim the programs that pay part of their costs back. See what applies to you in about 3 minutes. Free.

Free · 3 minutes · No SSN to start

See what I can get

What New York Medigap Plans Cost

DFS publishes a comparison of every insurer's monthly premium for each standardized plan, by region. The figures below are the lowest and highest monthly premiums listed statewide in the table for premiums in effect as of November 1, 2026. They are 2026 rates. Insurers file rate changes with DFS, and new rates usually take effect in January, so check the current table before you apply.

PlanLowest monthly premium listedHighest monthly premium listed
Plan A$192.75$413.53
Plan G$264.80$840.28
High-deductible Plan G$52.53$106.34
Plan K$96.86$200.86
Plan N$269.00$582.93

Source: NY DFS, "Comparison of Year 2026 Community Rated Standardized Medicare Supplement Monthly Premiums (Premiums in Effect as of November 1, 2026)."

Every Plan G pays the same benefits, by federal law. A Plan G at $264.80 and a Plan G at $840.28 cover the same bills. The price gap comes from the insurer and the region, not the coverage. The same holds for every other plan letter.

Prices also vary by where you live. For the same insurer, the Long Island, New York City and Westchester columns often run higher than upstate regions.

DFS pricing regions

DFS sorts premiums by the first three digits of your ZIP code.

RegionZIP codes starting with
Albany120 to 123, 128 to 129
Buffalo140 to 143, 147
Long Island110, 115 to 119
Mid-Hudson124 to 127
New York City100 to 104, 111 to 114
Rochester144 to 146
Syracuse130 to 132, 137 to 139, 148 to 149
Utica133 to 135
Watertown136
Westchester105 to 109

For your exact premium, use the DFS Medicare Supplement Rate Look-up tool or call the insurer. A premium shown for a region may apply to only part of it.

2027 Federal Medigap Figures

These amounts are set by CMS and apply in every state, including New York, from January 1, 2027.

Figure20262027
High-deductible Plan G (and F) deductible$2,950$3,050
Plan K out-of-pocket limit$8,000$8,360
Plan L out-of-pocket limit$4,000$4,180
Part D out-of-pocket cap (drug plans)$2,100$2,400
Part B deductible$283$292
Part B standard premium$202.90$209.40

Sources: CMS CY2027 Medigap deductible and out-of-pocket notices; CMS CY2027 Rate Announcement; CMS 2026 and 2027 Medicare Parts A and B fact sheets (2027 figures released November 17, 2026).

Plan G pays everything Plan F does except the Part B deductible. Medigap never covers prescription drugs, so you also need a separate Part D plan. For a side-by-side of every plan letter, see the Medicare Supplement Plans 2027 Comparison Chart.

Plan C and Plan F

If you became eligible for Medicare on or after January 1, 2020, insurers in New York may not sell you Plan C, Plan F or high-deductible Plan F. If you already have one of those plans, you can keep renewing it. If you were eligible before 2020 but did not enroll, you may still be able to buy them.

Medigap vs Medicare Advantage in New York

In most states, the biggest risk in choosing Medicare Advantage at 65 is that you may never get Medigap later without passing health questions. New York removes most of that risk. You can apply for Medigap in any month, and your health cannot be used to deny you or raise your price.

One timing rule still applies. Leaving a Medicare Advantage plan to return to Original Medicare is limited to set windows:

  • Annual Open Enrollment: October 15 to December 7, 2026, for coverage starting January 1, 2027.
  • Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment: January 1 to March 31, 2027, for people already in a Medicare Advantage plan.
  • Special Enrollment Periods: for example, after a move or when a plan leaves your area.

So the plan is: switch back to Original Medicare during one of those windows, apply for your Medigap policy so it starts the same day, and pick up a Part D plan. Medigap pays nothing if you are still enrolled in Medicare Advantage.

QuestionMedigap (with Original Medicare)Medicare Advantage
Monthly cost in New YorkMedigap premium plus Part B plus Part DPart B premium plus the plan's premium (often $0 premium)
Doctor choiceAny provider nationwide that accepts MedicareUsually a network
Out-of-pocket on careLow to none on Plan G after the Part B deductibleCopays and coinsurance, up to the plan's yearly limit
Can you switch later in NY?Yes, to Medicare Advantage during enrollment windowsYes, back to Medigap, year-round application once you leave Medicare Advantage

New York also limits what doctors who do not accept Medicare assignment can bill above Medicare's approved amount for most services (Public Health Law section 19). Office and home visits fall outside that state limit. Ask a doctor whether they accept assignment before you get care.

For the full national comparison, see Medicare Advantage vs Medigap 2026. If you are weighing a plan change during this enrollment season, see Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment 2027.

Help With Medicare Costs in New York

Medigap is not the only way to lower what Original Medicare leaves you owing. New York's Medicare Savings Program has higher income limits than the federal minimum and no asset limit for its QMB and QI levels.

ProgramWhat it paysCountable monthly income limit, 2026 (single)Couple
QMBPart A and Part B premiums, deductibles and coinsurance$1,836$2,489
QI-1Part B premium$2,474$3,355

Source: Neighborhood Legal Services (Buffalo), Medicare Savings Programs 2026, updated March 9, 2026. Countable income is after the $20 general income exclusion, so your gross income can be slightly higher.

If you qualify for QMB or full Medicaid, a Medigap policy usually adds little, because those programs already pay most of what Medigap would. People in a Medicare Savings Program also qualify for Extra Help, which lowers Part D costs. Apply through your county Department of Social Services, or the Human Resources Administration in New York City. The NY Medicaid Helpline is 1-800-541-2831.

How to Buy a Medigap Plan in New York: Step by Step

  1. Confirm you have Part A and Part B. Medigap only works with Original Medicare. If you are turning 65 or retiring from job coverage, sign up for Part B through Social Security first.
  2. Decide on a plan letter. Plan G and Plan N are common choices for people new to Medicare. High-deductible Plan G has a much lower premium but you pay the first $3,050 in 2027.
  3. Look up every insurer's price. Use the DFS rate look-up tool or the comparison tables with your ZIP code. Same plan letter, same benefits.
  4. Check the waiting period. Ask whether a pre-existing condition wait applies, and give the insurer proof of prior coverage if you have it.
  5. Apply directly with the insurer or through a licensed agent. You can apply any month. Ask for a start date that lines up with the end of your current coverage so there is no gap.
  6. Add a Part D drug plan. Medigap does not cover prescriptions. Compare Part D plans at Medicare.gov.
  7. Cancel your old coverage only after the new policy is confirmed. If you are leaving Medicare Advantage, do it during an allowed window.

You can get free, unbiased counseling from New York's HIICAP program at 1-800-701-0501.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I buy a Medigap plan in New York at any time?

Yes. New York law requires every insurer selling Medigap to accept your application in any month of the year, and it cannot deny you or charge more because of your health. A pre-existing condition waiting period of up to 6 months can apply, but prior creditable coverage with no gap longer than 63 days shortens or removes it.

Do New York Medigap premiums go up with age?

No. New York Medigap plans are community rated, so everyone in the same region pays the same premium for the same plan from the same insurer, regardless of age. Premiums still change when DFS approves an insurer's rate change.

How much does Medigap Plan G cost in New York?

As of November 1, 2026, DFS lists Plan G premiums from $264.80 to $840.28 a month statewide. The benefits are identical across insurers. Your price depends on the insurer and your ZIP code region.

Can I switch from Medicare Advantage back to Medigap in New York?

Yes. Leave Medicare Advantage during the Annual Open Enrollment (October 15 to December 7), the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment (January 1 to March 31), or a Special Enrollment Period. Then apply for Medigap, which New York insurers must accept regardless of your health.

Can I get Medigap in New York if I am under 65?

Yes. New York's year-round and no-health-question rules apply to people on Medicare due to disability or end-stage renal disease, not only to people 65 and older.

Does Medigap cover prescription drugs in New York?

No. Medigap plans sold today do not cover prescriptions. You need a separate Part D plan. In 2027, Part D out-of-pocket drug costs are capped at $2,400.

Who can help me compare New York Medigap plans?

HIICAP, New York's State Health Insurance Assistance Program, offers free one-on-one counseling at 1-800-701-0501. DFS also posts every insurer's premiums in its comparison tables and rate look-up tool.

The average person finds $16,900 a year in benefits they qualify for.

See your real number, and how to claim each one. Some you apply for yourself, and we tell you exactly where.

Free · 3 minutes · No SSN to start

See what I can get